Official wants state to offer juror therapy
Courtscases cause issues for some

By Jay F. Marks
Published: October 6, 2008

Rampant drug use. An illogical vendetta. Senseless violence, taken to extremes.

A jury of 12 Oklahoma County residents spent nearly three weeks dealing with those issues during the trial of Gilbert Ray Postelle, who was convicted in the 2004 killings of four people.

Advertisement

One juror was plagued by nightmares during the trail, her husband told the Oklahoma County district attorney’s office. He started attending the trial to reassure her, giving her a familiar face to turn to when things got tough.

"It doesn’t happen that often, but it does happen,” District Attorney David Prater said.

Prater said he would favor a program offering counseling to jurors, but nothing like that is available in Oklahoma County. He said the criminal justice system owes that kind of consideration to jurors in violent cases.

Post-trial programs
Jurisdictions in several states have post-trial debriefing programs meant to help jurors confront the emotions that emerged during their service. Texas passed a law last year providing up to 10 hours of counseling for jurors.

Even though there are no programs in Oklahoma, District Judge Ray Elliott said most criminal judges in Oklahoma County talk to jurors after a trial so they can express their feelings or ask questions.

"I think it works,” he said.

Being prepared
Oklahoma City attorney Cynthia Viol, who specializes in sex crimes, the kind of cases that often include disturbing testimony, said she does not think any kind of post-trial counseling is necessary if the jurors are adequately prepared in advance.

Viol represented an Oklahoma City man accused of child rape in an October 2006 trial that included a homemade videotape of the man having sex with a young boy.

One member of the jury that convicted Viol’s client ended up in counseling.

"In my opinion, it is a problem that should be addressed before the presentation of evidence during voir dire in difficult cases — not after the verdict is rendered,” Viol said.


Toolbar sponsored by: David Stanley Ford
Bookmark and Share



Comments

Thank you for joining our conversations on NewsOK.com. We encourage your discussions but ask that you stay within the bounds of our terms and conditions. Please help us by reporting comments that violate these guidelines. To review our rules of engagement, go to Commenting and posting policy.

Editor's note: It is not our intent to offer comments on crime or fatality stories.

Leave a comment. Log in below or sign up (it's free).

   
If you delete Tu as you have then PLEASE delete mine as well, as he said nothing wrong and only stated what he believed .I actually thought his were good comments!Delete mine as well please as it is not right that you leave only comments you must agree with.
Mollie, Oklahoma City - Oct 6, 2008 4:09 PM
Report as inappropriate
I wonder why they never delete mine? I get upset in mine and mispell words .This is my only way to get out what is happening to my son. I wish I was rich as I would bond him out and hire the best lawyer money could buy. Know one can really understand how bad things are unless they walk in someone in jails shoes, innocent or guilty.
Mollie, Oklahoma City - Oct 6, 2008 3:08 PM
Report as inappropriate
NO Therapy For Jurors..... They are asked if they can handle what they will see and hear in the case and they state they will be alright or they are excused. Let's get real. If Prater wants to do the right thing he will prosecute Joyce Gilchrist and Bob Macy for the crimes and murders they have committed. Oklahoma's court system will not be creditable until they are or death row, with an execution date.
Dude, Love - Oct 6, 2008 3:05 PM
Report as inappropriate
Tu, what happened to the other comment you wrote, did you take it off or the site? Just curious.
Mollie, Oklahoma City - Oct 6, 2008 2:19 PM
Report as inappropriate
tu ,you are sooo right. My son has not had a trial yet, and I am scared to death. Not of him ,as we and everyone that knows him, knows he is innocent and was set up, and I know if he gets a decent jury they will see this as well. I thought you had a right to a speedy trial? He has rotted in jail for 14 months. No medical care as it is not free, I can only sent him $25 a week and to see a nurse or Dr. costs out of the money I send him, and it costs if he is given any meds, he uses the money to buy food as only the DOC prisoners eat well, the ones who have not had a trial are given balonga sandwiches or beans 3 xs a day. He gets no vitamins or milk so his teeth are rotting and his health has went down. Sad enough to do to an American who is a crimnal, but one who is innocent it is sad beyond words. We treat monster prisoners better in Cuba. I spend about 12 to 16 hours a week listening to a busy signal when I call the jail to try and get a visit.Some times I get a visit sometimes I do not. Then I have to scream through a glass so he can hear me talk to him, I can not hear him very well at all as I am hearing inpaired ,I wear hearing aids but can not use in the jail setting as with all the people screaming so their family memember can hear , the hearing aids just do not work.I want to leave Oklahoma when this nightmare is over, I was born here and loved my State but now I feel only ashamed to be an Okie.
Mollie, Oklahoma City - Oct 6, 2008 1:50 PM
Report as inappropriate
What about giving therapy to men and woman who have to sit in Jail for over a year or more, waiting for trial,knowing they are innocent. My son has lost all he holds dear his kids, his job, his home, his truck, his car, his dogs. Why??a woman a ex wife of 3 weeks, who wanted him out of her life so she could be one hundred per cent from him to persue her life of women, men, sex and drugs, not caring that she destroyed her kids and husband of 17 years lives in the process. Do they get therapy? Do they get their lives back? Everyone sitting in jail or going to trial is not quilty, some were set up and lied about to get back at or get out of someones life. I know as my family is living this living nightmare, do we get therapy?
Mollie, Oklahoma City - Oct 6, 2008 11:34 AM
Report as inappropriate