Group fights immigration reform law

By Devona Walker
Published: September 25, 2007

The Latin American and Hispanic Affairs Advisory Council joined the ranks of those questioning the constitutionality of pending immigration enforcement legislation Monday.

Advertisement

The appointed board voted unanimously to send Oklahoma Gov. Brad Henry a letter, indicating the state law attempts to supersede federal law.

"Everybody is worried and seriously concerned,” said Guillermo Rojas, a Tulsa businessman, and advisory council member. "This is not just about immigration, this is racism.”

The council also endorsed an ongoing effort to have state Attorney General Drew Edmondson weigh in on whether the Oklahoma legislation is constitutional.

About the law
HB 1804, authored by Rep. Randy Terrill, R-Moore, makes it illegal to transport, conceal, and harbor or house illegal immigrants. Violation of this order would be considered a felony, punishable by no less than a year in prison or a $1,000 fine.

The Oklahoma Taxpayer and Citizens Protection Act provides additional stipulations that criminalize both hiring and schooling illegal immigrants.

Oklahoma's new immigration law, largely considered one of the most stringent in the nation, takes effect Nov. 1.

Reforms under way
In Rojas' hometown of Tulsa, some elements of the immigration enforcement reform already are under way.

The Tulsa County Sheriff's Department, in an effort to ramp up, recently graduated more than 30 deputies with dual training in immigration and customs enforcement.

"The only one who can stop it now is the attorney general, with his opinion, or a fight in federal court,” Rojas said of the Taxpayer and Citizens Protection Act, adding that he was very pessimistic about Gov. Henry's willingness to get in the fray at this point.

Attorney sees problems
About two weeks ago, attorney Carole Wangrund was at her wits' end. In her opinion, HB 1804 is not only unconstitutional, but it contains numerous vulnerabilities in terms of implementation.

For one, she says it will be impossible to enforce it without racial profiling.

For another, she says, it provides no provisions for federal compensation, in terms of the cost of implementation.

"We are giving up all of our rights in the name of national security,” Wangrund said. "And for some bizarre reason, we are picking on the Hispanics.

"They passed this incredibly unconstitutional mess, without understanding that federal law pre-empts it,” she added.

After dissecting the law, she formally asked Edmondson for a formal review and to issue a public opinion.

Oklahoma not alone
Constitutional or not, Oklahoma is not the only state that has chosen to address the federal issue with state law. Georgia was the first and arguably has the toughest legislation — the Security and Immigration Compliance Act. Some of the wording in the Georgia law was used in Oklahoma's.

Terrill, R-Moore, has said he is convinced Oklahoma's bill is the toughest in the nation.

What's next
•Edmondson has a month to review Wangrund's material and issue an opinion. He is not required by law to weigh in on the matter.

•Terrill will push for a second round of immigration reform in the next legislative session. Next year, reform efforts will center around making English the official language of Oklahoma through voter referendum.

•Terrill also has said he is confident Oklahoma's law will stand up to judicial scrutiny, and has accused opponents of the law of trying to use the courts to stop something voters want.


Toolbar sponsored by: David Stanley Ford
Bookmark and Share



Comments

Thank you for joining our conversations on NewsOK.com. We encourage your discussions but ask that you stay within the bounds of our terms and conditions. Please help us by reporting comments that violate these guidelines. To review our rules of engagement, go to Commenting and posting policy.

Editor's note: It is not our intent to offer comments on crime or fatality stories.

Leave a comment. Log in below or sign up (it's free).

   
The Federal Govt has failed both the system and the American Economy / People whom they are sworn to protect. Why ? special interests groups, greed, personal agendas' ? The State of Oklahoma has spoken. The people of Oklahoma, Legal Citizens of the USA have spoken. State Law must be adhered to for the preservation of the rights of the legal citizens of Oklahoma, and public peace ! Accountability of illegals must be attained to keep the checks & balances of government and law and order. We legal citizens are on record. The border to the south is a gaping hole in our Homeland Security. The US GOVT will not build the required barrier. How many terrorists enter our country USA daily ? How many illegals enter daily ? How many MS-13 Gang members smuggle drugs, committ homicides against legal Americans, promote prostitution in the USA ? How many illegals are soaking our welfare system ? People, it's time to get control before all of this get's out of hand and innocent people are injuried or killed because oF the federal governments negligence ! This is not a new problem in America. It's been here over 20 years and politicians have neglected their duties to protect the legal American Citizens of Oklahoma & other states of the union.
James, Del City - Oct 3, 2007 1:17 AM
Report as inappropriate
Amen Brother, I agree, The Mexican Govt is not going to change their national language to English for us ! The old saying; " When in Rome, do as the Romans do !"
James, Del City - Oct 3, 2007 1:05 AM
Report as inappropriate
we the United States born americans say speak English only. if you don't speak english, you don't need to be complaning . this is america not mexico. if you our here you obey the laws, if not go home.
kathy, kennett - Sep 29, 2007 12:20 PM
Report as inappropriate
WETBACKS GO HOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!
kathy, kennett - Sep 29, 2007 12:07 PM
Report as inappropriate
when lawmakers make it more important to focus on illegals than help provide for its own less fortunate citizens...what does that say? immigration will never work as long as there are disenchanted citizens. thanks for wasting yet another 2 years terrill. without your church support you would be another worthless lawyer teaching....because you cant do it yourself. go back to alva. and take your ugly wife and kid with you.
Randy, Moore - Sep 26, 2007 9:37 AM
Report as inappropriate
I just don't understand. This is about enforcing laws that are supposed to protect the well being of our nation. Could this be the beginning of the end for US stability?
James, Oklahoma City - Sep 25, 2007 10:24 AM
Report as inappropriate
If you're in this country illegally, you have no rights. None, nada, zip, zilch...comprende?

Don't let the door hit you in the ass on the way out.
Anonymous, Everywhere - Sep 25, 2007 7:46 AM
Report as inappropriate
I have read HB 1804 and didn't find even one racist word or phrase in it. It never mentions Mexicans, Asian or any other nationality. It never mentions what racial or ethnic group an illegal is. So how can this law be racist? It can't. If Hispanics are targeted, it is because they are the largest group of illegals, it only makes sense to go after the largest group first (then the next largest, and the next after that). In an article that ran in the Oklahoman 11/29/05 from Pew Hispanic Center
Out of the 10.3 million undocumented migrants (illegal aliens), most (81%) are from Latin America.
57% Mexico (5.9 million)
24% Other Latin American Countries (2.5 million)
9% Asia (1 million)
6% Europe & Canada (600 thousand)
4% Africa and other (400 thousand)
Mexicans have made themselves the largest group. Is that racist? Not in the least.
Larry, Oklahoma City - Sep 25, 2007 1:42 AM
Report as inappropriate